AI
Vague AI Instructions Get Vague Results. The Model Is Not the Problem
People show me AI output all the time, shaking their heads. "Terrible. Totally inaccurate."
I ask to see the prompt. It is one line: "Summarize the meeting."
That's it. No mention of who will read the summary. No hint of which decisions or action items matter. No length. The AI guessed, the guess missed, and the model took the blame.
I get why people write AI off this way. The answer looks wrong, so the conclusion is "the tool is wrong." But in my own daily work, the root cause is almost always on my side of the screen.
One line of prompt, ten paragraphs of expectation
I use AI every day for product work. Drafting PRDs, cleaning up meeting notes, hunting for gaps in specs, preparing material for my team. I also built an 8-channel content distribution system that I run entirely by myself.
So here is what I know. When the output is bad, I reopen my instruction. Nearly every time, I find the hole.
The problem is that everything is clear inside my head. I know the context. I know who the reader is. I know what "good" looks like. But the AI is not in my head. It only has the sentences I typed.
So an instruction that feels complete to me is half-finished to the model. And it will not say "hey, this is missing something." It fills the gap on its own, with the most common guess available.
That is why the result feels generic. The model isn't lazy. It is filling the empty space I left behind.
Four ways I write half-finished instructions
These are the patterns that wreck my results most often:
- Context left in my head. "Clean up this PRD." Clean for whom? An engineer, a boss, an investor? Those are three readers and three different documents.
- Adjectives with no measurement. "Make it short and engaging." Short means three sentences or one page? Engaging to whom? Words like these are easy to type and give the model nothing to hold on to.
- Several requests in one breath. "Summarize, translate, and suggest improvements." Usually the first two come out fine and the third is filler. Stack three tasks into one instruction and the model's attention splits.
- No stated goal. I say what I want done, not why. But the goal decides what matters and what can be cut.
The fourth one is the sneakiest. I still trip on it myself, because the goal feels like something that is "obviously clear."
When I started building my content distribution system, I asked the AI to "write engaging captions" for each channel. What came back could have been posted on anyone's account. I was annoyed, until I realized I had never said what my voice sounds like, who reads each channel, or what action I want from them.
Once I wrote all of that down, quality jumped. Same model. The only difference was that what lived in my head finally made it onto the screen.
The test I run before I hit enter
I have one simple test. Imagine handing this instruction to a smart new colleague who joined today. They don't know the project, don't know the team, and weren't in yesterday's meeting.
If they would come back with three questions, the AI needs those three answers too. So I write the answers first.
Usually I check four things:
- Who will read or use the result.
- What a finished result looks like, including length and format.
- One example I consider good, if I have one.
- What to avoid, if there is a clear boundary.
One more trick earns its keep. At the end of the prompt, I add: "If anything is unclear, ask me before you start." The AI holds back from guessing, and very often it asks about exactly the thing I forgot to write.
This does not make every prompt long. For a small task, one clear sentence is enough. The point is to write the parts that actually decide the outcome, not to write more.
An old habit, a sharper tool
I wasn't born good at this. Writing clear instructions is a habit built over twenty years as a product person, because my job has always been to write requirements so other people can execute without guessing.
That same habit is behind another pattern in my career: saving companies money. I was doing that long before AI was trendy. It added up to $4M+ per year, from many different initiatives. Process fixes, cost optimization, more efficient product decisions, and automation was just one of them. Back then, leverage like that took a senior position, a team of engineers, and expensive systems. Now AI is the sharpest tool for the same habit, and it can be taught to everyone on your team.
That is why I built the Applied-AI Certification and AI Circle. The tool is already in everyone's hands. What rarely gets trained is how to talk to it.
If you want to start on your own, try one thing tomorrow. Take one prompt that frustrated you this week and rewrite it using the four checks above. Compare the results. You will see the difference without switching models at all.
If you want to learn alongside people doing this same work every day, join AI Circle. We dig into prompts and workflows that hold up in real jobs.
If you lead a team and AI results at your company still feel inconsistent, the thing to train may be how your people give instructions. Program details for companies are on the corporate page.